Today, the United States will observe both Columbus Day and Indigenous People’s Day, a dual commemoration reflecting the complex legacy of Christopher Columbus and the historical impact of his arrival in the Americas. Columbus Day has long been celebrated as a federal holiday, honoring the Italian explorer’s arrival in 1492. Italian-American communities, in particular, have held Columbus in high regard, viewing the day as a celebration of Italian heritage and immigrant contributions to American society.
Originally marked by parades, festivals, and community events, Columbus Day became an official federal holiday in 1937, after lobbying efforts from the Knights of Columbus, a Catholic fraternal organization. The holiday aimed to honor Columbus’s role in world exploration and the contributions of Italian-Americans, who often faced discrimination in the U.S. at the time. Yet, as more awareness has grown around the impact of European colonization on Indigenous populations, the holiday’s celebration has come under scrutiny, leading to a shift in how the day is recognized across various states and cities.
In response to these concerns, many communities have adopted Indigenous People’s Day as an alternative to, or in conjunction with, Columbus Day. Indigenous People’s Day serves as a time to honor Native American cultures, histories, and contributions. It also provides a moment to recognize the hardships Indigenous communities faced following Columbus’s arrival, including displacement, loss of land, and cultural erasure. Indigenous advocates argue that Columbus’s arrival marked the beginning of centuries of suffering for Native peoples in the Americas, making it essential to reframe the day as one of remembrance and resilience rather than solely a celebration of European exploration.
The dual observance of Columbus Day and Indigenous People’s Day varies widely across the United States. Federal offices and many businesses remain closed, as Columbus Day is still recognized as a national holiday. However, states and local governments have the autonomy to choose which holidays to observe. For example, states like Hawaii, South Dakota, and Vermont have chosen to solely recognize Indigenous People’s Day, while others, including New York and Illinois, observe both days. The approach taken often reflects regional histories, the presence of Indigenous communities, and local advocacy efforts.
Public commemorations for Indigenous People’s Day often include educational events, cultural showcases, and discussions centered on Indigenous history, rights, and modern-day issues. Events may feature traditional music, dance, art, and storytelling by Indigenous groups, fostering a greater understanding of Native American cultures and their contributions to American society. In some areas, educators use the day as an opportunity to teach students about the history and achievements of Indigenous people, shifting away from narratives that solely focus on Columbus.
This shift in how the holiday is observed illustrates a growing awareness and sensitivity to the diverse narratives that shape American history. The conversation around Columbus Day and Indigenous People’s Day emphasizes the importance of re-examining historical events through multiple perspectives and acknowledging the full scope of their impacts. As the U.S. continues to grapple with its past, October 14, 2024, offers a day of reflection, not just on exploration and discovery but also on resilience, cultural identity, and the need for inclusive historical understanding.
Image is in the public domain and is licensed under the Pixabay Content License.